This article was originally published by Printing Impressions. To stay updated on the latest industry shifts, subscribe to their newsletter, Today on PIWorld.
For decades, the role of the Chief Information Officer (CIO) in the print and packaging industry has been defined by a paradoxical disconnect. While organizational charts frame the IT department as a strategic partner, the reality on the shop floor tells a different story. It is a story of "keeping the lights on"—a never-ending cycle of password resets, troubleshooting legacy press integrations, and patching broken EDI feeds. For the average IT lead in a print shop, the "strategic project" is a perpetual casualty, pushed from one quarter to the next, sacrificed on the altar of immediate operational survival.
This is not a failure of talent or leadership; it is a structural reality of the industry. However, the emergence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is providing the first genuine opportunity to break this cycle. By offloading the burden of reactive, low-level technical maintenance, AI promises to elevate the IT department from a glorified help desk to a group of genuine strategic thinkers.
The Structural Burden of Legacy IT
The historical model of IT in manufacturing has been governed by survival metrics. Success was measured by the absence of catastrophe: How fast did you close the ticket? How few complaints reached the plant manager? What was the server uptime? These metrics indicate that the plant did not burn down, but they fail to capture the most important question: Did technology actually drive profitability?
In the current landscape, the overwhelming majority of technology budgets and personnel are dedicated to maintaining legacy systems. What remains for innovation is often a rounding error. This status quo has been accepted for so long that the industry stopped viewing it as a problem—it simply became the definition of "IT."
The shift offered by AI is not about automating quoting or scheduling—those are surface-level improvements. The real shift is the liberation of human capital. By delegating the reactive, repetitive tasks to intelligent systems, IT personnel can finally lift their heads, identify systemic inefficiencies, and participate in high-level business decisions.
Reimagining Success: The Metric of "Time Returned"
To capitalize on this shift, the industry must pivot from measuring IT performance via ticket resolution to measuring "Time Returned to the Business."
Time returned is not an abstract concept; it is a measurable P&L driver. When AI handles the administrative heavy lifting, that time manifests in tangible ways:
- Operational Efficiency: Reducing press downtime caused by last-minute scheduling conflicts.
- Sales Productivity: Empowering customer service representatives (CSRs) to focus on client relationships and revenue growth, rather than rekeying job data into multiple, disconnected systems.
- Institutional Knowledge: Capturing the nuanced judgment of veteran estimators before they retire, effectively baking their expertise into the digital workflow.
If an AI implementation does not move the needle on these bottom-line metrics, it is merely expensive entertainment. For the industry to evolve, IT leaders must ensure that every hour reclaimed by AI is redirected toward the projects that were previously relegated to the back burner.
A Paradigm Shift in Procurement: Moving Away from "The Novel"
The print industry’s traditional approach to technology procurement is fundamentally at odds with the pace of the AI era. For years, the standard operating procedure has involved forming committees, drafting exhaustive "requirements documents" that read like novels, and enduring months of demos—all for a platform that might take 18 months to deploy.
By the time such systems go live, the market has shifted, and the technology is often already obsolete. In the AI era, this "big bang" approach is not just inefficient; it is dangerous. It forces leaders to make high-stakes decisions based on data that will be stale by the time the system is operational.
The most successful operations are now adopting a model of "small, reversible tests." This methodology includes:
- Ninety-Day Cycles: Defining a clear, measurable success metric before starting.
- Low Cost of Exit: Designing pilot programs that can be discarded without crippling the organization if they fail.
- Data-Driven Truth: Viewing a failed pilot not as a budget-meeting catastrophe, but as an inexpensive way to gain essential data.
Designing for reversibility rather than permanence is the most effective way to protect capital and accelerate digital transformation.
The Prerequisite: Fixing the Foundation
Before an organization can reap the benefits of AI, it must confront an uncomfortable truth: AI is only as intelligent as the data it is fed. In the print industry, the foundational data is frequently messy. Estimating logic is often trapped in a 15-year-old spreadsheet; job history is buried in an MIS that hasn’t been trusted since the last major update; and pricing rules exist only in the minds of key employees.
Attempting to layer AI over a fractured foundation will only accelerate the creation of errors. However, this is not a reason to delay adoption. Instead, it is the first "AI readiness" task. Every dollar spent cleaning data and standardizing logic yields an immediate return once a model begins to run against that trusted data.
The Role of IT: Strategy over Code
A common misconception in the current AI discourse is that IT teams should become "builders"—writing their own proprietary AI tools or custom-coding integrations from scratch. For a massive software firm, that might be a viable path. For a print and packaging business, it is a dangerous distraction.
Building is not the highest and best use of a print shop’s IT team. The AI tools that will truly move the business should be developed by specialized providers who offer the necessary governance, security, and accountability.
Instead, the IT team should be repositioned as the "architects of opportunity." They possess a unique view of the business that no other department has. They know exactly where the money leaks:
- Where the same job is being rekeyed three times.
- Where margins are being eroded by inconsistent estimating.
- Where presses sit idle due to communication gaps between software silos.
For years, these IT leaders have been too buried in help-desk tickets to voice these concerns in meetings that matter. By using AI to clear their calendars, leadership can bring these individuals into the room. They shouldn’t be asked to code the solution; they should be asked to point the organization toward where the biggest impacts can be made.
Implications for the Future
The implications of this shift are profound. When IT moves from a support function to a strategic partner, the culture of the entire company changes. It shifts from a reactive mindset—constantly putting out fires—to a proactive one, focused on continuous improvement and long-term viability.
As the industry moves deeper into the AI era, the companies that will lead are not necessarily those with the most capital to spend, but those that successfully leverage their IT teams to identify the "leaky buckets" in their workflow. The goal is not to turn IT into a software development house, but to turn them into the eyes and ears of the business.
In the final analysis, AI is the tool that finally allows the print industry to stop "keeping the lights on" and start building for the future. The help desk era is ending; the era of the strategic CIO is just beginning. The question for every print shop owner today is simple: Now that you have the time back, what will you actually build?
About the Author
